How each one heats
Radiators. Metal panels on the walls, usually under windows, with hot water flowing through them. They warm the air around them, which rises and circulates through the room. To give enough heat at a reasonable size, traditional radiators run on fairly hot water.
Underfloor heating. Pipe loops laid under the floor, embedded in a screed. The whole floor becomes a gently warm surface that heats by radiation, from the ground up. Because the surface is so large, the water can circulate at a much lower temperature.
Side by side
| Radiators | Underfloor heating | |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | Good, but warmer near the radiator | Very even, warm feet, no draughts |
| Water temperature | Higher | Low |
| Efficiency with a heat pump | Good if sized for low temperature | Excellent: the most efficient pairing |
| Response time | Quick to warm up | Slow to warm up and cool down |
| Works in an occupied home | Small to medium: pipes along skirting, false ceilings or trunking | Major: the floor comes up |
| New build or full renovation | Simple | Natural, planned from the start |
| Floor height | No impact | Adds a few centimetres |
| Decor | Takes wall space, limits furniture | Walls free; avoid thick rugs |
| Floor finish | Any | Tile and stone ideal; wood and vinyl if rated for it |
| Maintenance | Bleeding radiators, valves | Manifold, air vents and filter; the pipes need nothing |
Comfort: why underfloor heating feels different
With radiators, warm air rises and gathers near the ceiling, and temperature varies across the room: hot next to the radiator, cooler on the far side. With underfloor heating, heat comes from the whole floor, so temperature is very even from door to window and from floor to head height. That's why many people feel comfortable with the thermostat a degree or two lower than they'd need with radiators.
Running costs: water temperature matters
A heat pump's efficiency depends heavily on how hot it has to make the water. The lower the temperature, the less electricity it needs for the same heat. Underfloor heating runs on lukewarm water, which makes it the most efficient match for a heat pump. Radiators also work with heat pumps, but they need to be sized for lower water temperatures than traditional radiators, which can mean larger radiators or more of them.
See how the heat pump fits into the system on central heating and heat pumps.
Building work: often the deciding factor
If you live in the home and won't touch the floors: radiators are almost always the realistic choice. Pipes run along the skirting, through false ceilings or in discreet trunking, and installation goes room by room.
If it's a new build or a full renovation: underfloor heating fits naturally. Floor levels are planned from the start to include insulation, pipes and screed. See underfloor heating.
If the renovation is partial: combine them. Underfloor heating where the floor is being redone (living room, kitchen) and radiators elsewhere.
Response time and how you use the house
Underfloor heating has a lot of thermal inertia: it takes hours to warm up and stays warm long after you switch it off. It works best running continuously, at a steady temperature with gentle scheduling.
Radiators respond quickly: switch on and the room warms up soon after. They suit homes used at set times (weekends, holiday homes) or people who prefer to turn the heating on when they get home.
Holiday homes and part-time residents
This matters a lot for homes that stand empty for weeks. Underfloor heating can be kept at a low background temperature while you're away and brought up gradually before you arrive, ideally with a thermostat you can control remotely. Radiators heat the house from cold much faster, which is handy if you arrive unannounced. Either way, keeping some background heat in winter helps prevent damp, a common problem in Portuguese homes left closed.
The middle way: low-temperature radiators and fan coils
Between traditional radiators and underfloor heating there are in-between options designed for lukewarm water, and therefore for heat pumps:
- Low-temperature radiators: larger or with more surface area, they deliver the heat needed with cooler water. They install like normal radiators, without lifting floors.
- Fan coils: compact units with a fan that pushes air through a water coil. They heat quickly, take little space and some also cool in summer when connected to a reversible heat pump.
For an occupied home where you want a heat pump without lifting floors, these get close to underfloor efficiency without the works.
Three scenarios
An occupied apartment in Lisbon, no floor works. Radiators sized for low temperature, connected to a heat pump or electric boiler, with zone thermostats.
A villa under construction near Setúbal. Underfloor heating throughout, connected to a heat pump that also produces hot water. Air conditioning in the bedrooms for summer.
Renovating an older villa in Cascais. Underfloor heating on the ground floor, where the floor is being redone, and radiators upstairs to keep the original wooden floorboards.
Bathrooms: a special case
In bathrooms, a towel radiator connected to the central heating is often the best solution, even in a house with underfloor heating: it warms up quickly, dries towels and helps control humidity.
How much does it cost?
The price depends on the area, the solution, the heat source and whether it's new build or renovation. In general, underfloor heating costs more upfront than radiators, because it includes insulation, screed and more pipework, but it gives the best efficiency with a heat pump. We quote after the technical visit, with everything included spelled out.
If you're also considering air conditioning, read air conditioning vs heat pump: many homes end up with both.
Frequently asked questions
Yes, as long as that room has its own loop and controls. It's common in bathrooms and living rooms.
Sometimes. We check whether each radiator gives enough output at the heat pump's operating temperature; where one doesn't, only that one is replaced.
Not if the wood is suitable for underfloor heating and the water temperature is properly controlled. Very thick solid wood is less suitable.
Both are quiet. Underfloor heating has nothing visible and no air movement noise.
Yes, in a room being renovated, with its own loop and suitable temperature control, connected to the same heat source.
It depends on screed thickness and the starting temperature. It can take several hours, so it works best on a continuous schedule with small day-night variations.
Both need little. Radiators are bled now and then and their valves checked. With underfloor heating, the manifold, air vents and filter are checked; the pipes themselves need nothing. In both cases, the yearly check of the heat source is what matters most.
