How each one works
Electric water heater. An insulated tank with an electric element inside. The element heats the water like a kettle, and the insulation keeps it hot until you use it. Each kWh of electricity gives, at most, one kWh of heat in the water.
Heat pump water heater. Also an insulated tank, but instead of just an element it uses a small refrigerant circuit, like an air conditioner in reverse. It draws heat from the air (from the room it's in, or from outside through ducts) and transfers it to the water. For every kWh of electricity it uses, it delivers several times more heat. Most also have a backup element for very cold days or faster recovery.
Direct comparison
| Electric water heater | Heat pump water heater | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Low | Considerably higher |
| Running cost for the same hot water | Highest | Several times lower |
| Space | Small; fits in a bathroom, horizontally or in a niche | Larger, and needs air volume or ducts to the outside |
| Where it goes | Bathroom, kitchen, false ceiling | Laundry, garage, ventilated pantry, utility room |
| Noise | Silent | Has a fan and compressor; some noise, like a louder fridge |
| Heat-up time | Fast for small tanks | Slower in heat pump mode; the backup element helps |
| Typical sizes | 30 to 200 litres | Usually 200 or 300 litres |
| Maintenance | Anode, safety valve, descaling | The same, plus filter cleaning and circuit check |
| Installation | Simple | More demanding: right location, condensate, possibly ducts |
When an electric water heater is the better choice
- One or two people with low hot water use: the heat pump's savings take too long to pay back the price difference.
- Little space: small bathrooms with nowhere suitable for a heat pump.
- A home used part of the year: with little use, the extra investment doesn't pay off.
- A temporary fix before a bigger renovation where everything will be rethought.
For tank size and shape (vertical, horizontal or slim), see water heaters.
When a heat pump pays off
- Households of three or more showering daily: the more hot water you use, the faster the price difference comes back.
- Busy holiday rentals: lots of showers, every day, all season.
- There's a utility space: laundry, garage or storeroom with enough air, or the option of ducts to the outside.
- You're replacing a unit anyway: the price gap is smaller when you were going to buy a new water heater regardless.
See configurations on heat pumps.
Doing the maths
To compare for your own home, three numbers matter:
- How much hot water you use per day. A rule of thumb: 40 to 50 litres per person per day with normal showers.
- What your electricity costs, and whether you have a time-of-use tariff (bi-horária), which makes overnight heating cheaper for both.
- The price difference between the two, installed.
With an electric water heater, almost all the energy needed to heat the water comes from electricity, plus tank losses. With a heat pump, it's a fraction of that. Multiply the monthly difference by the months and you get the payback time. For larger families it's short; for a single person it may never arrive.
On a technical visit we run these numbers with you, using your figures.
Time-of-use tariffs and scheduling
Both store hot water, so both can heat when electricity is cheapest. With a time-of-use tariff, schedule heating for off-peak hours, usually overnight. A heat pump has one quirk: it works better when the air is warmer. If it uses outdoor air, some people prefer heating around midday, when it's milder, even outside the cheapest period. It depends on your tariff.
Will a heat pump fit in your home?
- Height: a 200 litre model is roughly the height of a fridge-freezer.
- Air volume: if it draws air from its own room, the room needs enough volume, such as a garage or laundry. Otherwise it's ducted outside.
- Condensate: it produces water that needs a drain.
- Weight: full of water it's heavy; the floor must take it.
- Noise: it shouldn't sit against a bedroom wall.
If these don't work, an electric water heater remains the practical choice.
Three scenarios
A studio in Lisbon, one person. A 50 to 80 litre water heater, ideally horizontal or slim if space is tight. A heat pump doesn't pay off.
A three-bedroom flat in Odivelas, family of four, enclosed laundry with a window. A 200 litre heat pump in the laundry, ducted outside so the room doesn't cool. High hot water use, faster payback.
A villa in Azeitão, five people, garage. A 300 litre heat pump in the garage. If you also want central heating, consider an air-to-water heat pump that does both: see central heating.
Installation matters
Whichever you choose:
- a safety valve on the cold inlet, with its discharge piped to the drain;
- a dedicated electrical circuit with proper protection (we're also electricians);
- for a heat pump, enough air volume or ducts, and condensate drainage;
- fill before switching on: powering an empty water heater burns out the element.
Signs your water heater needs attention
Whichever type you have, some signs mean it's time for a check, or a replacement:
- Water takes longer to heat, or runs out sooner than it used to. Often limescale on the element or a worn thermostat.
- Rust-coloured water from the hot tap only. The inside of the tank may be corroding; the anode protects against this and wears out over time.
- Dripping from the safety valve. Some dripping while heating is normal; constant dripping isn't.
- Water at the base of the tank. A leaking tank can't be repaired; it needs replacing.
- The breaker trips when it heats. Usually a faulty element. Switch it off and call a technician.
If your water heater is old and showing several of these signs, it's a good moment to weigh up both options calmly, before it fails on a cold morning.
Frequently asked questions
Yes. Indoors, the air in a garage or laundry stays fairly stable. With outdoor air, modern heat pumps cope well with the Lisbon and Setúbal climate, with the backup element for the coldest days.
Often, if there's space and ventilation. It's bigger than a small water heater; a 200 litre model is about the height of a fridge.
A little, because it takes heat from the air. In a garage or laundry it's usually irrelevant, and welcome in summer. If it bothers you, it can be ducted outside.
Usually a dedicated circuit on the fuse board, with the right protection for the appliance, is enough. On the technical visit we check the board and, if needed, make the change ourselves: we are also electricians.
If it's busy, with daily showers all season, usually yes. If it's let only a few weeks a year, an electric water heater makes more sense.
